If you’re searching for the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, you’re likely balancing flavor, convenience, and variety. The top choice for overall quality is the Di Fara Grandma Classic Pizza, known for its authentic taste and handcrafted appeal. For a quick, satisfying frozen option, the Red Baron Deep Dish Singles 4 Cheese Pizza offers convenience without sacrificing flavor. However, tradeoffs like freshness versus shelf life or gourmet versus mainstream options are key considerations. Continue reading for a detailed breakdown of each pick and what makes them stand out in this crowded pizza scene.
Get pool and patio gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The top overall pick balances authentic flavor with broad appeal, making it ideal for most pizza lovers.
- Frozen options like Red Baron and Freschetta excel in convenience but may lack the freshness of freshly made pies.
- Premium picks such as Di Fara emphasize traditional craftsmanship, often at a higher price point.
- Variety matters: some options focus on cheese medleys, others on classic toppings or gourmet ingredients.
- Tradeoffs between price, freshness, and convenience are central to choosing the right pizza in Myrtle Beach.
| 365 by Whole Foods Market Margherita Thin Crust Pizza |  | Best Overall for Quick, Quality Margherita Pizza | Brand: 365 by Whole Foods Market | Size: 10.2 OZ | Crust Type: Thin Crust | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Di Fara Grandma Classic Pizza |  | Best for Classic Grandma-Style Pizza Enthusiasts | Brand: Di Fara | Size: 19.58 OZ | Type: Grandma Classic Pizza | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Red Baron Deep Dish Singles 4 Cheese Pizza, 11.2 oz, 2 Count |  | Best for Quick, Single-Serve Deep Dish Cheese Pizza | Brand: Red Baron | Variety: Four Cheese | Size: 11.2 oz | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust 4-Cheese Medley Pizza |  | Best for Flavorful, Aromatic Homemade-Style Pizza | Brand: Freschetta | Size: 26.11 oz | Cheeses: Mozzarella, white cheddar, provolone, parmesan | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 365 by Whole Foods Market Four Cheese Pizza |  | Best for Family-Friendly, Easy Frozen Cheese Pizza | Brand: 365 by Whole Foods Market | Size: 15.8 oz | Type: Frozen Four Cheese Pizza | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Freschetta Canadian Bacon & Pineapple Naturally Rising Crust Pizza 27.51 oz |  | Best for Flavorful, Fresh-Baked Experience | Weight: 27.51 oz | Crust Type: Naturally Rising | Ingredients: Mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce, pineapple, Canadian bacon | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Frozen Pizza, 20.6 oz |  | Best for Convenience and Classic Flavors | Brand: Red Baron | Variety: Classic Pepperoni Pizza | Size: 20.6 oz | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| pizza myrtle beach | Brand | Size |
|---|---|---|
| 365 by Whole Foods Market Marg | 365 by Whole Foods Market | 10.2 OZ |
| Di Fara Grandma Classic Pizza | Di Fara | 19.58 OZ |
| Red Baron Deep Dish Singles 4 | Red Baron | 11.2 oz |
| Freschetta Naturally Rising Cr | Freschetta | 26.11 oz |
| 365 by Whole Foods Market Four | 365 by Whole Foods Market | 15.8 oz |
| Freschetta Canadian Bacon & Pi | — | — |
| Red Baron Classic Crust Pepper | Red Baron | 20.6 oz |
More Details on Our Top Picks
365 by Whole Foods Market Margherita Thin Crust Pizza
This frozen margherita pizza stands out for its focus on simple, high-quality ingredients like whole milk mozzarella and fresh basil, offering a crispy thin crust that appeals to purists. Compared with the Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust 4-Cheese Pizza, this option emphasizes flavor simplicity over elaborate cheese blends, making it ideal for those craving a straightforward Margherita. The quick 15-minute bake time makes it a convenient choice for busy weeknights. However, its limited topping variety might disappoint those seeking more complex or loaded pies. Overall, this pick makes the most sense for fans of classic, minimalist pizza who prioritize ingredient quality and speed.
Pros:- Simple, high-quality ingredients like basil and whole milk mozzarella
- Crispy, thin crust that crisps well in the oven
- Fast baking time of approximately 15 minutes
Cons:- Limited topping options for variety seekers
- Could feel too minimal for those expecting a hearty pizza
Best for: Pizza lovers who appreciate authentic margherita flavors and quick preparation.
Not ideal for: Those wanting loaded or complex toppings, or a more substantial crust experience.
- Brand:365 by Whole Foods Market
- Size:10.2 OZ
- Crust Type:Thin Crust
- Cheese:Whole Milk Mozzarella
- Bake Time:Approximately 15 minutes
Our verdict“This pizza is perfect for purists seeking a quick, authentic margherita experience with quality ingredients.”
Di Fara Grandma Classic Pizza
This frozen pizza from Di Fara captures the essence of grandma-style pies with its generous 19.58 oz size, offering a nostalgic, thick crust topped with a straightforward tomato sauce. Compared to the more refined 365 by Whole Foods Market Margherita, it caters to those craving a hearty, traditional pizza reminiscent of New York favorites. The lack of detailed ingredient info and the fact that it’s frozen means it may not match the freshness of a Di Fara pizzeria visit. It’s better suited for those who prioritize a substantial, comforting slice over ingredient transparency. This pick makes the most sense for fans of classic, filling, grandma-style pizza who want a familiar, generous portion at home.
Pros:- From the well-known Di Fara brand with a strong reputation
- Large 19.58 oz size provides a filling meal
- Classic grandma-style thick crust and straightforward toppings
Cons:- Lack of detailed ingredient or nutrition info in the listing
- Frozen and potentially less fresh than actual pizzeria experience
Best for: Fans of thick, hearty grandma-style pizza craving authentic flavor from a renowned pizzeria brand.
Not ideal for: Consumers seeking detailed ingredient transparency or a lighter, more refined pizza experience.
- Brand:Di Fara
- Size:19.58 OZ
- Type:Grandma Classic Pizza
- ASIN:B0GVPFKGR9
Our verdict“This pizza delivers a satisfying, traditional grandma-style experience, ideal for those wanting a hearty, familiar slice from a trusted name.”
Red Baron Deep Dish Singles 4 Cheese Pizza, 11.2 oz, 2 Count
Red Baron’s Deep Dish Singles excel in convenience, delivering two individual 11.2 oz pizzas with a crispy, buttery deep dish crust topped with a rich four-cheese blend. Compared to the Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust 4-Cheese Pizza, these are more portable and faster to prepare—just 2-3 minutes in the microwave. This makes them perfect for a quick lunch or a snack-sized dinner. However, the microwave preparation and smaller portion size may compromise the depth of flavor and crust texture compared to freshly baked options. This pick makes the most sense for busy individuals needing an instant, satisfying cheesy fix without sacrificing convenience.
Pros:- Quick microwave preparation in just 2-3 minutes
- Made with 100% real cheeses including mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, and parmesan
- Convenient single-serve size perfect for quick meals
Cons:- Microwave may not replicate oven-baked crust quality
- Relatively small portion size for a full meal
Best for: People seeking a quick, single-serving deep dish cheese pizza for lunch or snack.
Not ideal for: Those wanting a more authentic, oven-baked deep dish experience or larger portions.
- Brand:Red Baron
- Variety:Four Cheese
- Size:11.2 oz
- Count:2 pizzas
- Preparation:Microwave 2-3 minutes
Our verdict“This pizza offers quick, cheesy satisfaction ideal for busy days, though it trades off oven-fresh crust for speed and convenience.”
Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust 4-Cheese Medley Pizza
This Freschetta pizza shines with its naturally rising, scratch-made crust that fills your kitchen with the aroma of freshly baked bread. Compared to the 365 by Whole Foods Market Four Cheese Pizza, it offers a more indulgent, bakery-like crust combined with a rich blend of cheeses—mozzarella, white cheddar, provolone, and parmesan—that create a layered flavor profile. Its longer baking time of 19-23 minutes might be a drawback for those seeking quick meals, but it results in a more authentic baked texture. This pizza appeals to those who value a hearty, bread-like crust and a fresh-baked aroma, even if it means waiting a few extra minutes.
Pros:- Made with 100% real cheeses including mozzarella and parmesan
- Naturally rising, scratch-made crust with fresh-baked aroma
- No preservatives, emphasizing quality ingredients
Cons:- Longer bake time of 19-23 minutes
- Frozen format may not match fresh bakery quality
Best for: Home cooks who enjoy a more flavorful, bread-like crust and have time for a longer bake.
Not ideal for: People needing a quick, 10-minute frozen pizza solution or preferring thinner crusts.
- Brand:Freschetta
- Size:26.11 oz
- Cheeses:Mozzarella, white cheddar, provolone, parmesan
- Crust:Naturally rising, scratch-made
- Baking Instructions:Bake at 400°F for 19-23 minutes
Our verdict“Ideal for those who enjoy a hearty, aromatic pizza with a bakery-style crust, willing to wait a few extra minutes for flavor and texture.”
365 by Whole Foods Market Four Cheese Pizza
This four cheese pizza from 365 by Whole Foods offers a straightforward, family-friendly frozen meal option, with a balanced blend of cheeses including mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, and parmesan. Compared to the Red Baron Deep Dish Singles, it provides a larger, more traditional size and a more familiar crust, making it suitable for sharing or custom toppings. Its convenience makes it a go-to for quick dinners, but the limited product details leave some questions about ingredients and crust quality. This choice makes the most sense for families or individuals seeking a reliable, easy-to-prepare frozen cheese pizza without fuss.
Pros:- Convenient frozen meal with familiar cheese blend
- From Whole Foods’ private label brand, emphasizing quality
- Large enough for sharing or multiple servings
Cons:- Limited detailed information on ingredients and crust
- Less gourmet or innovative compared to premium options
Best for: Families or busy households looking for a simple, reliable frozen cheese pizza for quick meals.
Not ideal for: Gourmet pizza lovers seeking artisanal ingredients or a more sophisticated flavor profile.
- Brand:365 by Whole Foods Market
- Size:15.8 oz
- Type:Frozen Four Cheese Pizza
- ASIN:B0DNR86DM3
Our verdict“This pizza offers a dependable, family-friendly option for quick cheese cravings, with simplicity and convenience at its core.”
Freschetta Canadian Bacon & Pineapple Naturally Rising Crust Pizza 27.51 oz
This pizza stands out for its naturally rising crust, which mimics the texture and flavor of a freshly baked pie more closely than typical frozen options like Red Baron’s classic crust. The topping combination of real mozzarella, pineapple, and Canadian bacon offers a sweet and savory profile that appeals to those seeking a tropical twist on pizza. However, it requires oven baking and isn’t microwave-friendly, which can be a drawback for quick meals. Its ingredient list highlights real, high-quality toppings, but the flavor profile is somewhat limited to tropical and bacon flavors, making it less versatile for varied preferences. Compared to other frozen pizzas, this one emphasizes a more artisanal crust and fresh ingredients, though it sacrifices convenience and variety.
Pros:- Naturally rising crust offers a fresh-baked flavor and texture
- Topped with real mozzarella, pineapple, and Canadian bacon for authentic ingredients
- Easy to prepare in the oven, with straightforward baking instructions
Cons:- Requires oven baking, not suitable for microwave reheating
- Contains processed ingredients, limiting appeal for health-conscious buyers
- Limited flavor versatility, focused mainly on tropical and bacon themes
Best for: Pizza lovers craving a flavor-rich, slightly gourmet frozen option with a tropical twist
Not ideal for: Those needing a quick, microwave-ready meal or a more traditional flavor profile
- Weight:27.51 oz
- Crust Type:Naturally Rising
- Ingredients:Mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce, pineapple, Canadian bacon
- Preparation:Bake at 400°F for 20-24 minutes
Our verdict“This pizza is ideal for those seeking a flavorful, bakery-style crust with high-quality toppings, willing to bake for a better taste experience.”
Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Frozen Pizza, 20.6 oz
Compared with the Freschetta option, the Red Baron Classic Crust offers a more straightforward, balanced pizza with a traditional crust that appeals to many pizza purists. Its 100% real mozzarella cheese and pre-cooked pepperoni ensure a familiar, satisfying flavor. The crust strikes a good balance—crispy enough without being too thick—making it suitable for quick dinners. However, as a frozen pizza, it can’t quite match the freshness or nuanced flavors of a pizzeria or freshly baked pie. Its smaller size and standard toppings make it less appealing for those wanting gourmet or tropical flavors but perfect for busy nights when convenience takes precedence.
Pros:- Made with 100% real mozzarella cheese and pre-cooked premium pepperoni
- Balanced crust with just the right amount of crunch and thickness
- Quick to prepare—bakes in under 20 minutes on the oven rack
Cons:- Frozen quality may not match fresh or pizzeria experience
- Limited flavor variety—focused solely on classic pepperoni
- Less emphasis on artisanal crust or ingredient quality compared to premium options
Best for: Busy households needing a quick, reliable pepperoni pizza with a classic taste
Not ideal for: Gourmet pizza enthusiasts or those seeking unique, tropical, or artisanal toppings
- Brand:Red Baron
- Variety:Classic Pepperoni Pizza
- Size:20.6 oz
- Storage:Frozen
- Crust:Classic
- Cheese:100% real mozzarella
- Baking Instructions:Bake on oven rack at 400°F for 18-21 minutes
Our verdict“This pizza makes the most sense for those prioritizing convenience and traditional flavors over gourmet or tropical options.”
How We Picked
Each product was selected based on a combination of flavor profile, ingredient quality, ease of preparation, and overall value. We prioritized options that balance taste with accessibility, considering both fresh and frozen varieties. Our ranking reflects a mix of consumer convenience, authenticity, and price, aiming to help different buyer types find their ideal pizza. We also evaluated how well each product captures the local Myrtle Beach vibe and whether it offers a unique or standard experience, ensuring a comprehensive overview for all preferences.Factors to Consider When Choosing Pizza Myrtle Beach
When choosing the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, it’s important to consider factors beyond just flavor. Your decision may depend on how you plan to serve the pizza, your budget, and your taste preferences. Understanding these key considerations can help you avoid common pitfalls, such as choosing a pizza that’s too greasy or not filling enough. Here are the main factors to keep in mind:Type of Pizza (Fresh vs. Frozen)
Deciding between fresh and frozen pizza significantly impacts flavor, convenience, and freshness. Freshly made pies usually offer richer flavors and a more authentic experience, but they require planning and may be less available in convenience stores. Frozen options, on the other hand, provide quick, easy solutions with a longer shelf life, ideal for last-minute cravings or busy schedules. Consider your priorities and how often you’ll be enjoying pizza to choose the best type for your needs.
Crust Style
The crust sets the foundation for your pizza experience. Thin crusts tend to be crisp and allow toppings to shine, making them perfect for those who prefer a lighter bite. Thick or deep-dish crusts offer more doughy satisfaction and can hold more toppings, appealing to bigger appetites or those craving a hearty slice. Choosing the right crust depends on personal preference and how you like your pizza to feel with each bite.
Ingredient Quality
Higher-quality ingredients often translate into better flavor and a more satisfying meal. Look for options that use real cheese, fresh toppings, and natural ingredients, especially if you’re opting for premium or gourmet pizzas. Cheaper or processed ingredients may save money upfront but can compromise taste and texture. Balance your budget with your desire for quality, especially if you’re seeking an authentic Myrtle Beach pizza experience.
Price and Value
Cost is a key consideration, but it isn’t the only factor. Sometimes, paying a bit more yields a significantly better product, especially for fresh, handcrafted pizzas. Conversely, frozen or store-brand options can provide excellent value if you’re seeking quick, everyday meals. Think about how often you’ll be eating pizza and whether a higher initial investment is justified by superior flavor or convenience.
Local Flavor and Specialties
Myrtle Beach offers unique local pizza options that reflect regional tastes, such as seafood toppings or coastal-inspired flavors. Incorporating local ingredients or styles can elevate your pizza experience, making it more memorable. When choosing, consider whether you want a traditional slice or something that captures the local Myrtle Beach vibe, especially if you’re a visitor eager to try regional specialties.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is frozen pizza a good option for a quick meal in Myrtle Beach?
Frozen pizza can be a convenient and satisfying choice when you’re short on time or looking for a quick meal. Modern frozen options often incorporate quality ingredients and can be easily prepared in minutes, making them suitable for busy schedules. However, they typically lack the fresh, artisanal quality of made-to-order pies, so consider your priorities—if flavor authenticity is key, a fresh or local pizzeria might be preferable.
What should I look for in a good pizza crust in Myrtle Beach?
The crust is the backbone of your pizza experience. If you prefer a crispy bite, opt for thin or hand-tossed styles. For a more filling, doughy experience, a deep-dish or thick crust works well. Quality crusts are usually made with simple, natural ingredients and have a good balance of texture and flavor. Consider the style that matches your taste and the toppings you plan to enjoy.
Are local Myrtle Beach pizzerias worth trying over store-bought options?
Local pizzerias often feature recipes that reflect regional tastes and use fresher ingredients, making them a worthwhile choice for a more authentic experience. They also tend to offer unique toppings or coastal-inspired flavors that you can’t find in standard store-bought options. If you’re seeking a taste of Myrtle Beach, trying a local spot can provide a memorable, regionally inspired pizza experience.
How do I choose between different cheese varieties on my pizza?
The type of cheese affects flavor, meltability, and texture. Classic mozzarella offers a mild, creamy baseline that pairs well with most toppings. Cheddar adds sharpness, while cheeses like provolone or gouda provide richer, more complex flavors. Some frozen options blend multiple cheeses for added depth. Consider your flavor preferences and whether you want a traditional or gourmet profile when selecting your pizza.
Is it worth paying more for gourmet or artisanal pizza in Myrtle Beach?
Investing in gourmet or artisanal pizza often means higher-quality ingredients, unique flavor combinations, and a more crafted experience. These options can be especially rewarding if you’re celebrating or seeking a special meal. However, they generally come at a higher price point and may be less convenient. If authenticity and flavor complexity matter most to you, spending a bit more can be a worthwhile upgrade.
Conclusion
For those seeking a reliable, all-around excellent pizza experience in Myrtle Beach, the Di Fara Grandma Classic Pizza stands out as the best overall choice, offering a blend of authenticity and flavor. Budget-conscious buyers who prioritize convenience will find the Red Baron Deep Dish Singles 4 Cheese Pizza to be a great value. If you’re after a premium, artisanal experience, then the handcrafted options like Di Fara are worth the extra investment. Beginners or visitors eager to try regional flavors might prefer local pizzerias or more straightforward frozen options. Ultimately, your choice depends on your taste, occasion, and how much effort you’re willing to invest in your pizza cravings.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
